The Most Popular See’s Candies

When you’ve been making candy for over a century, you tend to learn a thing or two about what people truly love. At See’s, we’ve seen customers fall head over heels for just about every piece of candy, but a few sweet standouts never seem to leave the spotlight.

Whether you’re a lifelong fan or stopping by a See’s shop for the first time, you might be wondering: What are See’s best candies? What do people keep coming back for? And most importantly… What should I try? No matter the question, we’re here to help.

Consider this your one-stop shop (well, blog post) for all things candy: everything from See’s top sellers to timeless classics that have helped define our legacy. So, let’s unwrap the delicious details together, shall we?

15 Popular See’s Candies

1. Dark Scotchmallow®

If we had a candy hall of fame, this piece would be in the front row. Our Dark Scotchmallow® layers honey marshmallow over buttery vanilla caramel, then wraps it all in rich dark chocolate. One bite of this chewy masterpiece and you’ll see why it’s one of our most popular See’s pieces, and why fans scoop them up so fast.

2. Milk Bordeaux™

Just think of creamy, brown sugar centers coated in See’s signature milk chocolate, and topped with a generous piling of chocolate sprinkles. If your mouth is watering already, you’re not alone. This creamy, melt-in-your-mouth deliciousness is what makes our Milk Bordeaux™ one of See’s top sellers, year after year.

3. Milk Butterscotch Square

If “can’t-put-it-down” were a treat, it’d be the Milk Butterscotch Square. With a center made of brown sugar, heavy cream and a splash of vanilla, then drenched in milk chocolate, it’s a sweet, buttery bite people can’t get enough of.

4. Molasses Chips

The chocolate is rich, the crunch is real and the satisfaction is immediate. Our Molasses Chips are light, honeycomb wafers flavored with molasses and dipped in milk or dark chocolate. They come lined in a tray ready for serious snacking and have earned their spot amongst See’s best candies. We challenge you to eat only one without going in for seconds. Good luck.

5. Milk California Brittle®

Some chocolates are crunchy. Some are buttery. Milk California Brittle® is both! We take our classic toffee, mix in some roasted almonds and cover it with creamy milk chocolate. The result? A sweet-and-salty bite that’s simply nostalgic. Once you try it, you’ll understand why it’s been holding strong as one of See’s best pieces for generations.

6. Peanut Brittle

This is more than candy, it’s a piece of See’s history. Made with Mary See’s original recipe (yes, the same recipe that has been used since 1921), our Peanut Brittle is packed with roasted peanuts and a perfectly golden, buttery crunch. It’s one of our most iconic treats and easily one of the best See’s candies to gift. Every crunch carries a taste of tradition.

7. Butterscotch Lollypop

If you’ve ever had one, you already know what we’re about to say. If you haven’t? Welcome to a lifelong obsession. Our Butterscotch Lollypop is made with heavy cream and butter and takes on-the-go snacking to a whole other level. The irresistibly smooth and rich flavor keeps fans, both young and old, coming back for more.

8. Dark Salted Caramel

Sweet meets salty in the most sophisticated way. With a soft, brown sugar caramel center enrobed in dark chocolate and topped with a sprinkle of salt, our Dark Salted Caramel has become a modern-day classic.

9. Dark Chocolate Buttercream

If you think chocolate is best served rich, smooth and deeply indulgent, then this piece is for you. Our Dark Chocolate Buttercream is a luscious, melt-in-your-mouth chocolate liquor soft center wrapped in, you guessed it, smooth dark chocolate. It’s the chocolate lover’s chocolate, through and through.

10. Dark Raspberry Cream

A smooth, raspberry-flavored center wrapped in aged dark chocolate, the Dark Raspberry Cream is smooth, slightly tangy and refreshing. It’s one of the most popular See’s pieces for fruit lovers, and a go-to pick for anyone with a soft spot for berries.

11. Polar Bear Paw®

Roasted, salted peanuts and buttery caramel come together under a smooth layer of white chocolate to create a sweet-and-salty treat you won’t want to share. This fan favorite has a loyal following, and for good reason. Once you try a Polar Bear Paw® you’ll understand why it’s always sold out and why people love to stock up on these treats year-round. Oh, the irony.

12. Milk Caramel Pattie

Our Milk Caramel Pattie is simple, classic and entirely satisfying. With a soft, vanilla caramel center and a coating of smooth milk chocolate, this piece has always remained near the top of every See’s fan's most beloved pieces. It goes to show that sometimes, less really is more.

13. Toffee-ettes®

A legend. Our iconic Toffee-ettes® are made with buttery toffee, roasted almonds and a generous coating of milk chocolate. These bite-sized confections are crunchy, nutty and effortlessly snackable. Keep a tin nearby and you’ll see why they’re one of See’s most popular pieces.

14. Milk Peanut Butter Pattie

If peanut butter and chocolate are your love language, just stop what you’re doing and grab our Milk Peanut Butter Pattie now. With a creamy, peanut butter center drenched in milk chocolate, what more could you ask for? It’s the candy equivalent of a warm hug.

15. Milk Almond Square

Some fan favorites earn their spot with their creativity and unique flavor; Milk Almond Square is no exception. It’s made with roasted almonds folded into soft, vanilla caramel and dipped halfway into creamy milk chocolate. If you’re the kind of person who loves texture and rich flavor in every bite, this piece is a no-brainer.

Which Popular See’s Piece Is for You?

There it is, some of the most beloved and best-selling See’s treats, each with their own story and unique flavor. Now that you’ve met the lineup, it’s time to find the pieces that speak to your sweet tooth.

With our Custom Mix option, you can pick up to 10 different candy varieties and create a personalized box packed with exactly what you want. Mix and match classic pieces and new finds to craft your ultimate candy experience, because sometimes, the best box is the one you build yourself.

So, what are you waiting for? Dive in, explore and make your sweet dreams a reality with some of the most popular See’s Candies today!

Related Topics:

• See’s Candies Top 10 Caramel and Butterscotch Candies

• See’s Top 10 Milk Chocolate Candies

• See’s Top 10 Dark Chocolate Candies